Cuil the New Useless Search Engine
Whenever something claimed to be the “Google-killer” coming out from the closet, everyone went Wow! So here we have it, Cuil, from the old Irish word for knowledge, claimed to have indexed 121 billion pages.
Cuil searches more pages on the Web than anyone else.three times as many as Google and ten times as many as Microsoft.
Rather than rely on superficial popularity metrics, Cuil searches for and ranks pages based on their content and relevance. When we find a page with your keywords, we stay on that page and analyze the rest of its content, its concepts, their inter-relationships and the page.s coherency.
Hey that is cool! The interface looks very Web 2.0′ish (gradient, rounded corners, big constrast. etc). Let’s check how good it is on search. So I searched my name, Scott Yang on Cuil:
Nice. This blog is the very last item on the SERP with a totally irrelavent image next to it. Someone’s LinkedIn profile is the first result — but not mine. And the rest of SERP? There are full of those “Scott Yang School of Obesity” links. WTF?! School of Obesity? Is it trying to tell me something?!
I’ve tried to search with many specific terms and none gave me satisfactory search result. Yes — none. At the end of the day, it does not matter whether you have indexed 120 billion pages or 120 trillion googol pages. If your SERP does not yield useful result, then you too are irrelevent. Next!
Comments
I agree. A search for my name comes up with nothing useful. I thought the algorithm and index might not be tuned towards people so I tried searching for “Saxophone wx50″ (which is a wind midi instrument for those of you not familiar with it !) it can up with…… NOTHING !!! Google found 54 entries with a supposedly smaller index. Big index means nothing.
Actually, my bad. it should be “saxophone WX-5″ and it did come up with some results, not great though.
cuil=pretty sucky. searched our business and my partner’s name–which comes up smack top three on google. nada. none showed up on the first FOUR pages! i say google killed them before they got out of the water.
At least you got listed. I entered “Dean Peters” and “church website design” (with quotes) and got NOTHING of relevance to me …
… for “Dean Peters” … alot of links about a now-dead professional wrestler, and some obscure rapper.
… for “church website design” … mostly commercial CMS providers for churches.
So if I wanted to look up tutorial information on how to maintain my church website, I’m out of luck.
I thought Cuil will improve after 3 months in existence, but it can’t still find my blog! and they said they indexed 120 billion pages? Find.com and even the much newer mse360 are better. these two found my blog and give interesting results..
Add a comment
Gravatar is used. Email address is required but will not be displayed. Please keep your comment on topic. No spamming and/or bad language. First time poster will be moderated. Scott reserves the right to delete/edit your comments.
Playground is the personal weblog of Scott Yang, a Chinese-Australian Christian who works as a software developer in Sydney Australia.
I don’t get three columns, and it’s not even a grid – incredibly hard to scan.
The images appearing next to search results half the time are not from the site being listed – very strange.
But, how did they get so much PR? They’re in newspapers and all over blogs. Although if like me, you get wacky results, you’ll head straight back to Google.